Homemade Cookie Butter Spread Recipe

If you’ve ever tasted that irresistible cookie butter in stores and wished you could make your very own at home, then you’re in for a treat! This Homemade Cookie Butter Spread Recipe is my go-to for satisfying that sweet, spiced craving without any of the mystery ingredients. It’s so simple to whip up and perfectly smooth, with just the right hint of cinnamon and vanilla. Trust me, after making this once, you’ll find yourself reaching for it daily—whether it’s on toast, drizzled over ice cream, or just by the spoonful straight from the jar.

this …

Ingredients You’ll Need

This recipe is all about balance—the spicy warmth of gingersnap cookies, the creaminess from milk and butter, and a perfect touch of vanilla and cinnamon. Each ingredient plays a role in creating that dreamy cookie butter texture and flavor you’re craving.

• Gingersnap cookies: These are the heart of the spread—use a good quality crunchy kind for the best flavor and texture.
• Whole milk: Adds creaminess and helps blend the cookies into a smooth spread; you can add a splash more if you want it thinner.
• Unsalted butter: I always use unsalted so I can better control the saltiness—plus, it adds richness.
• Vanilla extract: Just a splash gives the spread a lovely fragrant sweetness.
• Ground cinnamon: It adds cozy warmth and depth, so don’t skip this!
• Powdered sugar: Helps sweeten the spread smoothly without grit.
• Fine sea salt: Balances the sweetness and intensifies the flavors.

Variations

I love playing around with this recipe — it’s surprisingly forgiving, so you can really customize it to your liking without stress. Whether you want it dairy-free, a little spicier, or even chocolatey, there’s plenty of room to experiment.

• Dairy-free version: Swap the whole milk for coconut milk and use vegan butter for a delicious dairy-free spread.
• Extra spice kick: Add a pinch of ground ginger or nutmeg along with the cinnamon for a more warming, complex flavor.
• Chocolate chip swirl: Stir in mini chocolate chips after blending for crunchy pockets of chocolate goodness.
• Less sweet option: Reduce powdered sugar to make it fit perfectly on your low-sugar diet.

How to Make Homemade Cookie Butter Spread Recipe

Step 1: Crush and Blend the Cookies

First, pour your gingersnap cookies into a blender or food processor. I usually break them up a bit with my hands before adding for easier blending. Pulse a few times until you get fine crumbs — it’s okay if some slightly larger chunks remain; they’ll blend out in the next step.

Step 2: Add Milk, Butter, and Flavorings

Now add the whole milk, unsalted butter, vanilla extract, ground cinnamon, powdered sugar, and sea salt. I like to add the milk little by little—start with the 1/4 cup and then add more if you want a thinner, spreadable consistency. Blend everything together on high until silky smooth and creamy. It usually takes about 2-3 minutes, but watch closely so the mixture doesn’t overheat.

Step 3: Taste and Adjust

Give your cookie butter a taste. If you want it sweeter, add a dusting more powdered sugar; if it needs more warmth, a pinch more cinnamon works wonders. Blend again for a few seconds if you make any additions. Once you’re happy with the flavor and texture, transfer to a clean jar or container.

Step 4: Serve or Store

You can enjoy your homemade cookie butter spread immediately — it’s amazing right away! Or cover tightly and store it in the refrigerator for up to two weeks. Just bring it back to room temp before spreading.

How to Serve Homemade Cookie Butter Spread Recipe

Garnishes

I find a simple sprinkle of extra cinnamon on top is charming and enhances the warmth of the spread. For special occasions, a few crushed gingersnap crumbs or a drizzle of melted chocolate can add a festive touch that your guests will adore.

Side Dishes

This cookie butter spread is perfect alongside a warm slice of buttered toast, pancakes, or waffles. I also love pairing it with apple slices or drizzling over vanilla ice cream—my family goes crazy for this combo during movie nights!

Creative Ways to Present

For a brunch or dessert party, I like serving the cookie butter in a cute jar with a tiny wooden spoon. You could even make a cookie butter board with fresh fruit, nuts, crackers, and mini toast points for guests to dip and spread—it’s always a hit!

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

I store leftover cookie butter in an airtight container in the fridge where it keeps beautifully for up to two weeks. Before using, I let it sit on the counter for 20-30 minutes to soften for easy spreading.

Freezing

While I haven’t frozen this homemade cookie butter often, I have tried storing it in the freezer ahead of a big batch prep. Just thaw overnight in the fridge and stir gently before serving to restore its creamy texture.

Reheating

If your spread gets too firm in the fridge or freezer, I warm it gently in the microwave for about 10-15 seconds or place the container in a bowl of warm water. Stir well and it softens up nicely without losing that delicious flavor.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

Honestly, this Homemade Cookie Butter Spread Recipe has become one of those little kitchen treasures for me. Its ease and versatility make it a staple—it’s perfect whether you’re indulging yourself or sharing with friends and family. I love that it’s made from simple ingredients that you probably already have laying around, and the taste? Pure comfort in a jar. Give it a try, and I bet it’ll quickly become one of your favorites too!

Print